By the time educators become education leaders, they have (often) been teachers and assistant principals who excelled in their roles. This is why they are promoted: they have a track record of “getting things right.” They are used to being recognized and rewarded for their success and ostensibly are expected by their supervisors and the communities they serve to “get results.” This common biography of many leaders is often accompanied by an allergy to mistakes. Instead, they have a strong predisposition toward planning, and a “git er done” work ethic that prioritizes productivity and efficiency over the discomfort of uncertainty.
Ironically this profile adds up to immunity to learning. Education influencer Todd Whitaker says, “When the principal sneezes, the whole school catches a cold,” so when leaders habituate always perfect performance, the school itself adopts an immunity to learning which trickles down to students. The result is what middle school principal Cynthia Beers described as “studenting:” when students merely go through the motions of what we’ve tacitly agreed are the actions that look like learning. Studenting is going to class, turning in assignments, getting grades, checking off boxes. But studenting can be done without thinking, reflection, or change.
This brief article further explains how our expertise can get in the way of learning.
Psychological safety guru Amy Edmondson offers key distinctions among types of failure, honing our failures toward those we can learn from.
In this classic by Chris Argyris, he describes the organizational tendency toward “skilled incompetence” which is an immunity to learn, and what can be done to overcome it.